Tuesday, June 30, 2009

China's Ancient Silk Road City Of Kashgar Facing Threat Of Bulldozers


China's Ancient Silk Road City Of Kashgar Facing Threat Of Bulldozers

Demolition has begun in parts of Kashgar's Old City.
June 30, 2009
By Antoine Blua
The ancient Silk Road trading hub of Kashgar, in China's northwest Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, is being threatened by an ambitious government redevelopment plan that some say has a hidden political agenda.

Kashgar's old city has survived the centuries, and remains an important Islamic cultural center for the Uyghurs, the Turkic ethnic group living in Xinjiang.

According to Matthew Hu Xinyu, an adviser to the nongovernmental Beijing Cultural Protection Center, the densely packed houses and narrow lanes of old Kashgar are the best-preserved examples of a traditional Islamic city in all of China.

Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Province in northwest China
But the government's reconstruction plan, Hu says, is threatening to destroy the picturesque labyrinth that makes up old Kashgar.

"Last fall, I heard that the plan would be carried out through the next three years. I thought we would have some time to organize experts or architects to work on a constructive plan -- to suggest a more conservative plan -- so that the city's heritage can be preserved," Hu said. "But early this year the total investment for the plan has been increased to [$440 million], and the demolition of the old houses started very quickly."

City officials have been moving a number of families out of Kashgar's city center, saying they need to rebuild old, dangerous houses and improve infrastructure. In total, the government says it plans to renovate or reconstruct more than 5 million square meters of old homes and resettle some 45,000 households.

Officials say the project is necessary because an earthquake could destroy old buildings, putting residents at risk. Indeed, earthquakes frequently rock Xinjiang. In 2003, a quake killed some 270 people.

Reports say wrecking crews razed the historic Xanliq madrasah, one of the province's protected cultural sites, on June 15. Mahmud al-Kashgari, the 11th-century scholar, is believed to have studied at the madrasah.

Traditional Lives

Dominated by a gigantic statue of Mao, old Kashgar has seen many changes in recent decades, including the construction of a main street running through the old town center. Cars, buses, and trucks clog the city streets.

If we have the houses removed and rebuilt, then this layout will disappear, and the significance of the city will disappear.
Still, many residents manage to live a far more traditional life. They live in tumbledown mud-brick rentals or two-story homes that open onto courtyards. Artisans hammer metal bowls, pans, and pots, carve wood, and hone brightly decorated knives.

Street vendors sell hand-made candy, fresh mutton, or hand-sewn skull caps. Donkey-cart drivers navigate the narrow streets.

It’s unclear what will remain of the design and way of life of the city, which is hundreds of years old, after the reconstruction project is completed. The city says important buildings will be preserved, while many homes will be rebuilt to better withstand earthquakes while still preserving Uyghur building styles. However, several sectors are expected to be rebuilt with modern apartment buildings, public plazas, and schools.

Officials say infrastructure such as water, electricity, and sewers systems also will be installed.

No Details Forthcoming

The Beijing Cultural Protection Center says nobody denies Uyghurs the right to development, modernization, and security. But the center worries that it has been unable to obtain any details of the reconstruction plan, which Hu says should ensure the preservation of the city’s unique heritage.

A gate in Kashgar's Old City
“If we look at every single one of these Uyghur people's homes [individually], it's not significant, [although] some of them have very interesting carvings on the door frame or on the architecture, the wooden parts," Hu says.

"But this group of [homes] shows a way of life [and] a way of urban planning -- how the city can be organized around different mosques. If we have the houses removed and rebuilt, then this layout will disappear, and the significance of the city will disappear," he said.

China and Central Asian states support a plan to propose major Silk Road sites for inclusion on the UNESCO World Heritage List, an incentive for governments to preserve areas of historical and cultural significance.

Beijing, however, has not included old Kashgar in its list of proposed sites.

Henryk Szadziewski, manager of the Uyghur Human Rights Project in Washington, D.C., taught for several years in Kashgar in the 1990s. He tells RFE/RL that there's no clear indication of what is going to be done with the remaining old city.

"As far as we understand the project, a remainder of the old city would be left, I imagine, to attract tourists. But who is going to manage that area and profit from the tourist revenue?" Szadziewski asks. "The tourist industry is worth about [$90 million] a year in Kashgar. We also have to remember that we have no indication that there was any meaningful participatory process that meant that the old city residents were party to the decision making."

Political Aspects Seen

The preservation of Kashgar's old town is facing challenges similar to those facing the preservation of other Chinese cities. But many see a political aspect to the redevelopment project in Kashgar, which Chinese officials consider a breeding ground for Uyghur separatism.

Chinese officials in recent years have alleged that Kashgar harbors terrorist cells. Uyghur extremists were blamed for a fatal attack on border police; two of the alleged organizers were executed this spring.

Uyghurs at a bazaar in Kashgar
Many see the Kashgar project as an attempt to remove the cultural roots of Uyghur separatism.

“There's definitely a difference between what's happening in eastern China and in Kashgar. That's largely due to the sensitivity over the Uyghurs and their particular concerns over human rights issues," Szadziewski says.

"The [Kashgar] project appears to be a tool to assimilate Uyghurs and to actually stifle peaceful dissent by putting old city residents from an organic living arrangement into a regimented, government-organized living arrangement. The [Chinese] authorities are able to monitor the activity of any peaceful dissent among Uyghurs,” he says.

Szadziewski says the assimilation process is taking place on many different fronts.

“One particular area is language, and we've seen a marginalization of Uyghur language in the economic sphere and the educational sphere," he says. "A 'China Daily' report said that learning Mandarin Chinese will help fight terrorism. The statement in itself may cast a sort of aspersion on Uyghur language itself, that it was a suspect language."

Critics accuse Beijing of using claims of terrorism as an excuse to crack down on peaceful pro-independence sentiment and expressions of Uyghur identity.

Monday, June 29, 2009

Turkey's Gul becomes first president to visit East Turkistan





Turkey's Gul becomes first president to visit East Turkistan
Gul is the first Turkish president visiting this autonomous region where almost 9.3 million Uyghur Turks are living.
Monday, 29 June 2009 12:42



World Bulletin / News Desk

Turkish President Abdullah Gul received Nur Bekri, chairman of the East Turkistan in Urumchi on Monday and Wang Lequan, secretary of Regional Committee of the Communist Party of China (CPC)

Andolu news agency said the Turkish president arrived in the capital city of East Turkistan on Sunday, the last leg of his formal visit to China. President Gul is visiting the region upon an invitation of the Beijing administration.



The meetings at Yin Du Hotel were closed to press. Gul later attended a luncheon hosted in his honor by Bekri.



Turkish Interior Minister Besir Atalay, Turkish ambassador in Beijing Murat Esenli, Chinese officials and local officials from East Turkistan, that China calls it "the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region", attended the luncheon as well.

"Uyghurs like a bridge of friendship"

Gul said on Monday that the region was an important element that connected Turkey and China to each other.



Paying a visit to "Xinjiang" University, Gul was presented with the title of Honorary Professor by the university's rector.

Addressing a group of academicians and students, Gul said that Turkey desired to improve its economic relations with all the regions in China.



Gul said, "Uyghurs act like a bridge of friendship between Turkey and China. Such role will contribute to the further improvement of our relations".

Gul also visited Kiziltepe Park of Urumchi together with the city's mayor and Turkish ambassador in Beijing Murat Esenli.



Gul is the first Turkish president visiting this autonomous region where almost 9.3 million Uyghur Turks are living.

Historical records show that the Uyghurs have a history of more than 4000 years. Throughout the history the Uyghurs developed a unique culture and civilization and made remarkable contribution to the civilization of the world.



After embracing Islam the Uyghurs continued to preserve their cultural dominance in Central Asia. Uyghur earned world renowned-scholars in many fields.

East Turkistan was occupied by the communist China in 1949 and its name was changed in 1955. The communist China has been excersizing a colonial rule over the East Turkistan since then

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Recruitment for State Jobs in Xinjiang Discriminates Against Ethnic Minorities

Recruitment for State Jobs in Xinjiang Discriminates Against Ethnic Minorities

Ethnic minorities in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (XUAR) continue to face widespread discrimination in recruitment for state jobs, according to Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC) analysis of recent recruiting efforts for jobs in the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps (XPCC) and XUAR schools. The recent recruitment programs follow other examples of discriminatory job recruiting practices in the XUAR and come during a period of high unemployment for XUAR college graduates.

Discrimination in Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps Continues
The Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps (XPCC) has announced plans to recruit for 894 positions, of which 744 have been reserved for Han Chinese, according to rosters of available job openings. (See an index of job openings posted May 7 on the Bingtuan Personnel Testing Authority Web site to download the rosters.) Of the remaining positions, 137 are specified as unrestricted by ethnicity and thus are open to applicants of all ethnic groups including Han, while 11 positions are reserved for Uyghurs and 2 positions are reserved for Kazakhs. The job recruitment follows earlier discriminatory hiring practices in the XPCC documented by the CECC in 2006. All of the positions advertised in the 2009 XPCC recruiting program require at least a technical or college degree. The positions include jobs in employing agencies such as government bureaus, Communist Party committee offices, the XPCC court system, and prisons. All candidates must take the job recruitment exam in Mandarin Chinese, according to information on the job recruiting program posted May 7 on the Bingtuan Personnel Testing Authority Web site. (For additional information on the 2009 XPCC job recruitment, see also a brochure posted May 7 on the Bingtuan Personnel Testing Authority Web site and an article posted May 8 on the Kashgar district government Web site.)

As noted in previous analysis by the CECC, the Chinese government established the XPCC in 1954 as a means of settling demobilized soldiers and Han migrants to perform border defense functions and to support economic development. The central government's 2003 White Paper on the History and Development of Xinjiang says that the ranks of the XPCC are now "a mosaic of people from 37 ethnic groups, including the Han, Uygur, Kazak, Hui, and Mongolian." The White Paper describes the XPCC as "a special social organization, which handles its own administrative and judicial affairs" but "in accordance with the laws and regulations of the state and the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region." As noted by the CECC, Chinese law forbids discrimination based on ethnicity. Within this framework of non-discrimination, several provisions in Chinese laws stipulate measures to promote the hiring of ethnic minorities.

Teaching Positions Discriminate Against Ethnic Minorities
Recent job recruitment announcements from one district and one autonomous prefecture in the XUAR also indicate widespread discrimination against ethnic minorities during the recruitment process for jobs in XUAR schools. In Aqsu district, 347 of 436 open positions in district schools are reserved for Han Chinese, while the remaining 89 positions are reserved for Uyghurs, according to a roster of open positions. (See an announcement on the job openings posted May 8 on the Shayar county government Web site to download the roster of job openings.) In addition to the restrictions based on ethnicity, candidates must not believe in a religion or participate in religious activities, according to the May 8 announcement. In the Bayangol Mongol Autonomous Prefecture within the XUAR, 413 of almost 500 jobs in local schools are reserved exclusively for Han Chinese, according to a list of open positions. (See a May 4 brochure on the Southern Xinjiang Personnel Net to download the roster.) In addition, 37 positions are specified as unrestricted by ethnicity and thus are open to applicants of all ethnic groups including Han, while 26 positions are reserved for Uyghurs and 10 exclusively for Mongols. In addition, 5 posts are open either for Han or Mongol candidates.

Available information on the job recruitment in Aqsu and Bayangol indicates that the ethnicity-based categories are not proxies for language skills, as the positions contain separate stipulations regarding language capability, in addition to ethnicity-based restrictions. (XUAR schools traditionally have offered separate tracks of schooling in Mandarin and in ethnic minority languages, though such tracking has diminished with the implementation of Mandarin-centered "bilingual" education.) According to the recruiting announcement from Aqsu district, ethnic minority candidates must meet a minimum requirement on a national Mandarin Chinese exam. In addition, 56 of the 89 positions for Uyghurs are reserved for Uyghurs who received their schooling in Mandarin-language schools (minkaohan students), according to the roster of open positions in Aqsu. The announcement on job recruitment in the Bayangol Mongol Autonomous Prefecture specifies that ethnic minorities whose native language (mother tongue, or muyu) is Mandarin Chinese may apply for positions reserved for Han Chinese, thereby appearing to exclude ethnic minority candidates who are fluent in Mandarin (such as minkaohan students who learned Mandarin in school), but do not speak it as their native language.

Graduates Face High Unemployment Rates
The barriers to employment for ethnic minority job candidates come during a period of high unemployment in the XUAR. XUAR authorities have pledged to boost employment and to focus on increasing job prospects for ethnic minorities, but the evidence of ongoing discriminatory practices, along with limited information on implementation of policies to promote employment of ethnic minorities, call such a stated focus into question.

According to a March 2 article from the XUAR Ethnic Affairs Commission (via the State Ethnic Affairs Commission) and March 10 China Daily report, the government has pledged to sustain an employment rate of over 70 percent for recent XUAR college graduates through measures including programs that send medical and educational workers to rural areas and through the establishment of job training bases. The rural jobs and training bases will focus on hiring and training ethnic minorities, according to the reports. Since making the pledge, authorities have reported on efforts to create new jobs for college graduates, though some information has had limited or no information on increasing job prospects for ethnic minorities. An April 16 article from Xinhua Xinjiang reported that the region has established over 7,000 spots for university graduates in the job training bases. The article did not include information on efforts to encourage training of ethnic minority graduates. A May 18 article from Xinhua Xinjiang noted that as of the end of April, only 22.1 percent of college graduates in the XUAR had signed employment contracts, down 1.49 percent from the previous year. The article reported that a government official outlined steps to spur employment, including through job recruitment for positions in the government and XPCC. (The government has also filled XPCC positions with people from outside the XUAR. See information on efforts to recruit approximately 4,400 college graduates from Gansu province for XPCC jobs, as reported in an April 10 China Ethnicities News report, via the State Ethnic Affairs Commission. The percentage of college graduates who signed employment contracts in the XUAR compares with an unofficial estimated nationwide figure for college graduates of 33 percent as of March 2009, according to an April 3 report posted on the Xinyang, Henan province, Personnel Bureau Web site.) At the same time it reported on job opportunities in the XPCC, shown by the CECC to exclude most ethnic minority candidates, the May 18 article said the government would focus employment assistance work on giving priority to hiring and providing benefits to ethnic minority graduates and graduates with difficulties finding employment. An April 15 government notice, posted May 22 on Tianshan Net, provided information on a program to send graduates to work in rural areas, but neither the notice nor accompanying materials provided information on promoting the hiring of ethnic minorities. Information on civil servant hiring in the XUAR has given some information on ethnicity-based restrictions and efforts to promote the hiring of ethnic minorities. Of 6,558 open civil servant positions in the XUAR government, the government has both left "the majority of positions unrestricted by ethnicity," thereby open to candidates of all ethnic groups including Han, and has "reserved a set amount of positions" for ethnic minorities, according to a May 12 report from the Xinjiang Personnel Department.

The continuation of government-sponsored discriminatory job recruitment practices in the XUAR accompanies broader policies in the region that also violate the rights of ethnic minority citizens. For more information on conditions in the XUAR, see Section IV--Xinjiang in the CECC 2008 Annual Report.

Demolition of Kashgar's Old City Draws Concerns Over Cultural Heritage Protection, Population Resettlement

Demolition of Kashgar's Old City Draws Concerns Over Cultural Heritage Protection, Population Resettlement

Authorities in a city in western China have launched a demolition project that has undermined the preservation of a cornerstone of the Uyghur ethnic group's cultural heritage and will result in the resettlement of roughly half the city's population. Official Chinese media have described the project to "reconstruct" the historic Old City section of Kashgar, in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (XUAR), as a way to address infrastructure shortcomings and to guard against risk of earthquake damage. Chinese sources indicate that most of the existing buildings in the Old City will be demolished rather than restored. Overseas media have reported that authorities have undertaken the project despite opposition from local residents and have compelled residents to leave their homes, with reported cases of inadequate compensation. While reflecting ongoing problems across China with property seizure, resettlement, and heritage protection, the Kashgar demolition project also reflects features unique to the region. The XUAR is a government-designated ethnic minority autonomous region with legal protections for ethnic minority rights, including protections for culture and cultural heritage, but in practice, central and local government authorities exert tight controls in the region that undermine the protection of residents' rights and also impede available avenues for challenging government actions. Implementation of the project, which had been in the planning stages for several years, also coincides with a period of heightened repression in the region since early 2008. See Section IV--Xinjiang in the Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC) 2008 Annual Report for general information on conditions in the region and see below for more information and analysis of the Kashgar project.

Chinese Government and Chinese Media Accounts of the Project--50,000 Households To Be Resettled
Under a 30 billion yuan (US$4.39 billion) project launched in late February with funds from the central and XUAR governments, authorities will "reconstruct" the Old City of Kashgar within a five-year period and resettle roughly 50,000 households, or more than 200,000 people, according to reports from Chinese government and media sources. Based on the reports, the number of people affected approaches half of the Kashgar city population. (For information on the planning stages of the project, see an August 13, 2008, report from the Kashgar district government Web site describing a meeting of government and Communist Party officials to address construction plans. For reports from the initial stages of construction and resettlement in February, see February 27 reports from Xinjiang Daily and Xinjiang News Net (1, 2), and a February 28 report from China News Net. For subsequent reporting, see a March 27 article from the Kashgar district government Web site, detailed report from Yaxin dated March 23, May 27 report from Xinhua Xinjiang, and June 8 Yaxin report. Figures on the exact number of people and households affected, as reported in these articles, varies.) According to the August report from the Kashgar district government, the project to "reconstruct" the Old City has received longstanding central government attention, and the impetus to implement it came after the May 2008 earthquake in Sichuan province. The Yaxin article reported that nearly 60% of the Old City houses, made of clay and wood, date from the 1950s and 1960s, and that poor construction has impeded infrastructure improvements and made the area vulnerable to earthquake damage. The information in the Yaxin report conflicts with earlier government reporting on the age of the buildings in the Old City. A 2007 report on the Kashgar district government Web site describes many of the buildings as older than 400 years old and describes most individual residences as more than 50 to 80 years old, with some as old as 150 years old.

Demolition and Resettlement Plans Linked to Ethnic Issues
In addition to stated concerns about earthquakes, the first February 27 Xinjiang News Net report said the dangers posed by the buildings also affected factors including "economic development, ethnic unity, and the reinforcement of Xinjiang's borders." In the August article, a government official also raised political concerns, describing Kashgar as an area where Uyghurs are most heavily concentrated and an area in the "front ranks" in the XUAR's fight against separatism, terrorism, and infiltration.

According to the February articles and March Yaxin article, the first group of residents affected by the initial stages of the project have been resettled in earthquake-proof high-rises in a suburb of the city. The Yaxin article reported that all the Old City families resettled as a result of the project will receive monetary compensation or replacement housing. Authorities will also take measures to establish businesses to help sustain the livelihoods of relocated populations, according to the report. The August 2008 article reported that some 23,000 subsistence-level and lower-income households affected by the project would "mainly be provided with low-cost rental housing or affordable housing to facilitate relocation," while residents "with resources but unwilling to leave" would receive subsidies for building new earthquake-proof housing on site or elsewhere. According to the August report, as of that date, the XUAR government already had re-designated townships in the Kashgar suburbs as towns and begun converting farmland in preparation for resettling affected populations. The report described efforts to distribute propaganda materials and launch "ideological mobilization" to garner support for the project. See also the March 23 Yaxin report for additional information on mobilizing support for the project by broadcasting images of the Sichuan earthquake. Overseas media reports, citing local residents, have challenged the adequacy of compensation and scope of local support for the project. See below for details.

Earlier plans to address infrastructure in the Old City date to a 2001 "Implementing Project for Safeguarding the Famous Historical and Cultural City of Kashgar and Taking Precautions to Quake-Proof the Old City" according to the Yaxin report. (See the 2007 Kashgar government report for additional information on earlier efforts to address the issue starting in 1999.) The 2001 project planned to invest 600 million yuan (US$87.8 million) into reinforcing and safeguarding key residences and relics, but came to a halt due to various factors including funding, according to the Yaxin report. Under existing efforts launched since 2001 to earthquake-proof the area, 2,500 households already have moved to earthquake-resistant housing, according to the second Xinjiang News Net report and a February 2 report from the Kashgar district government Web site. Authorities also have carried out other efforts to demolish and reconstruct parts of Kashgar. See, e.g., a July 16, 2005, Telegraph article on demolitions near the Id Kah mosque.

Preservation Efforts Minimal--Most Buildings To Be Demolished
Details of the Kashgar demolition project indicate shortcomings in both the project's capacity to protect the cultural heritage of the Old City as well as in the Chinese government's overall framework for cultural heritage protection, including as it relates to ethnic minorities' right to preserve their culture. At the August 2008 meeting to discuss the "reconstruction" of the Old City, as reported in the August 2008 article, officials indicated that efforts to preserve existing structures would be minimal. While authorities from various government agencies took part in the meeting, no officials from cultural heritage offices were reported to attend. Speaking at the event, the Kashgar district Communist Party secretary described the "reconstruction" of the Old City as a "human-centered" project and stressed that "what [the project] will protect is a construction style with ethnic features, and what it won't protect is dangerous old raw earth houses that endanger the people's safety." Noting that the Old City contained the world's largest complex of raw earth structures, a government official spoke of the importance of preserving the "historical style and regional features" of the Old City, but cautioned against wide-scale preservation:

The reconstruction of the Old City must take place under the premise of protecting historical and regional features, but some experts and scholars propose retaining the original appearance of Kashgar's Old City, and we think that [view] is out of touch with reality. Preservation of the people's lives, property, and safety must be placed first. Otherwise, if a fairly large earthquake strikes, not only will the people's lives and property receive damage, but the historic area will similarly be destroyed in a flash. Moreover, according to general surveys, buildings in the Old City with real historic preservation value are very few. We'll resolutely protect the buildings with historic preservation value, but we can't take every old and shabby building and keep them all. The facts will inevitably show that the Old City after its reconstruction not only will not have destroyed the Uyghurs' history and culture but will have inherited and developed the Uyghurs' history and culture. Using the excuse of protecting the history and culture of a famous old city to impede the Old City's restructuring shows extreme irresponsibility toward the safety of the lives of the 220,000 Old City residents of all ethnicities.

The official added that recently constructed buildings would be renovated to make them earthquake-proof, while the "few" buildings with preservation value would be repaired and reinforced. The official did not provide details on the process of determining which buildings have preservation value. According to a May 27 New York Times article, officials report that at least 85 percent of the area will be demolished. Authorities cited in the article said they would rebuild some parts of the Old City using a "Uyghur style" of architecture, in line with the Kashgar district Communist Party secretary's statement on using "a construction style with ethnic features." The statements did not provide additional information on how such "ethnic features" or "Uyghur styles" are defined. (For an example of interpretations of "Islamic-style" architecture and "ethnic character" within a reconstruction project in a Hui Muslim neighborhood in Beijing, see pp. 146-148 within Daniel B. Abramson, "The Aesthetics of City-scale Preservation Policy in Beijing," Planning Perspectives, Vol. 22, No. 2 (April 2007): 129-166.) According to a book cited in the New York Times article, describing Kashgar before the Old City demolition, "Kashgar is the best-preserved example of a traditional Islamic city to be found anywhere in Central Asia" (George Michell, Kashgar: Oasis City on China's Old Silk Road, Frances Lincoln, 2008, p. 79). The 2007 report from the Kashgar government Web site also stressed the historic character of the Old City and expressed support for preservation principles.

The Kashgar Communist Party secretary did not address how the determination that few buildings hold preservation value relates to Kashgar's designation as a national-level historic and cultural city with historic districts within the Old City. Kashgar received the designation in 1986, as recorded in a government notice from that year. (See also the 2007 Kashgar government report for information on historic districts within the city.) The 1986 designation adheres to a 1982 notice on preserving cities with historic value or significance to China's modern revolutionary history. Since then, the Chinese government has codified its process for designating and protecting historic cities into a Regulation on the Protection of Famous Historic and Cultural Cities, Towns, and Villages (Historic Cities Regulation). Both the Historic Cities Regulation and article 14 of the broader Law on the Protection of Cultural Heritage call for preservation efforts for designated historic areas, and article 28 of the Historic Cities Regulation specifically forbids new construction or expansion in the centers of historic districts, with the exception of infrastructure installation. The article also details the procedures for gaining permission to carry out construction. Despite stipulating protections for historic areas, some provisions within the regulation are poorly defined, thus appearing to permit wide latitude in determining what kind of structures qualify for legal protections. For example, article 47(1) of the Historic Cities Regulation defines historic architecture (which is protected under the regulation) to mean certain structures designated by the government that "have definite preservation value and can reflect historical styles and regional features." The regulation does not detail how or by whom "preservation value" and ethnic and local "features" are defined, calling into question the capacity of Chinese law for effective cultural heritage preservation, including as it accords with ethnic minorities' right to define and protect their culture, and the state's obligation to secure this right.

In the case of the Kashgar project, ambiguities in the framework for heritage protection contribute to the formal leeway for authorities to take a narrow view of which structures have historic value and qualify for protection, thus removing most of the buildings in the Old City from the formal protections of the Historic Cities Regulation. Authorities also have excluded possible international mechanisms to preserve the Old City that would have come with its inclusion on a list of proposed Silk Road locations for entry in the UNESCO World Heritage List. (The Silk Road list's proposed sites include cities, but exclude locations within Kashgar except for the tomb of Mehmud Qeshqeri.) See the New York Times article for additional information. The Chinese government has formally committed itself to preserve its cultural heritage not only through its domestic legislation but also through its ratification of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention.

Details of the project also suggest that authorities have bypassed ways to protect Old City residents' safety while preserving existing buildings. Standards set by professionals in the field of cultural heritage preservation indicate compatibility between historic preservation and measures to guard against natural disaster. Articles 10 and 14 of the Charter for the Conservation of Historic Towns and Urban Areas, adopted by the non-governmental International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) and available on its Web site, recognize the importance of introducing "contemporary elements" and preventative measures against natural disasters while ensuring they are "adapted to the specific character of the properties concerned." Scholar Ronald Knapp, cited in a May 3 National report, said that in the case of the 2008 earthquake in Sichuan province, problems came about “more from very poor ‘modern’ construction rather than the shortcomings of traditional practices.”

XUAR Residents, NGO, Overseas Observers Object to Project
Reports from overseas media have indicated opposition to the project from local residents and some local officials, as well as concerns from local residents and outside observers about housing resettlement and historic preservation. A report from a Beijing-based NGO also has expressed concern about historic preservation and raised questions about procedural aspects of the project. (See the May 27 New York Times article, May 3 National report, March 25 and April 2 reports from Radio Free Asia (RFA), a March 24 Washington Post article, March 24 Uyghur American Association (UAA) press release, March 26 South China Morning Post article (subscription required), April 3 article from openDemocracy, and undated report from the Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Center.) An official from the Kashgar cultural relics management office, cited in the April 2 RFA report, said that the project was being implemented without adequate attention to historic preservation, and another official expressed concern about resettled residents' ability to sustain their livelihoods, many of which were tied to workshops within the Old City. The UAA press release raised concerns that the population resettlement would increase government capacity to "control and monitor Uyghur activity" and pressure Uyghurs to assimilate. The openDemocracy article questioned the nature of future reconstruction in the city given a track record of co-opting cultural practices and redeveloping ethnic minority areas elsewhere in China to boost tourism. Kashgar was designated one of "China's superior tourist cities" in 2004, according to a report that year from Tianshan Net. Authorities plan to rebuild part of the Old City as an "international heritage scenery" site to attract tourism, according to the National article.

Information from overseas reports also raise questions about the process of consulting with residents on the project and on adequate compensation. Two men cited in the National report said they had received no information about compensation and did not know where they would be relocated to, while other sources said that the government had not consulted with them about the demolition. Some Kashgar residents cited in the New York Times article said that compensation amounts were inadequate. Sources cited in both the Washington Post article and March 25 RFA report indicated dissatisfaction with the project but said they lacked the means to challenge the government. A source cited in the RFA article noted that people felt scared to voice their opinions. China's Historic Cities Regulation specifies that authorities must solicit opinions from the public for restructuring projects (article 29). International standards also carve out a role for public input in preservation projects. Article 17(c) of UNESCO's Recommendation Concerning the Safeguarding and Contemporary Role of Historic Areas calls for authorities to include the opinions and participation of the public. Article 3 of the ICOMOS Charter for the Conservation of Historic Towns and Urban Areas states, "The participation and the involvement of the residents are essential for the success of the conservation programme and should be encouraged. The conservation of historic towns and urban areas concerns their residents first of all." Article 5 states, "The conservation plan should be supported by the residents of the historic area."

The report from the Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Center, a Beijing-based Chinese NGO, emphasized the preservation value of the Old City and expressed concern about procedural aspects of the project. The report noted the lack of detailed information on preservation efforts, including the full text of the city's preservation plan. Chapter 3 of the Historic Cities Regulation stipulates that the governments of areas designated as historic cities must prepare and implement a preservation plan. The regulation also details other procedural steps necessary to alter designated historic areas. See, for example, articles 28 - 32 on provisions regarding infrastructure construction in designated historic areas. A December 12, 2008, article from the Kashgar government reports that officials submitted plans for the current reconstruction project to examination by scholars, which adheres to article 29 of the regulation.

Shortcomings in Property Protection
The complaints by residents affected by the project reflect continuing problems with property seizure and resettlement in China. China's 2007 Property Law, which protects private property rights, addresses expropriation of and compensation for property (article 42). As noted in a recent examination of the law by legal scholar Mo Zhang, however, "the Property Law sets no standard or requirement to guarantee a fair and just process for the taking." (Mo Zhang, "From Public to Private: The Newly Enacted Chinese Property Law and the Protection of Property Rights in China," Berkeley Business Law Journal, Vol. 5, 2008, Temple University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2008-39, p. 360, available through the Social Science Research Network Web site.) The Property Law also lacks a clear standard for "what constitutes the public interest to justify a taking" (p. 361). Among existing regulations that address takings, Zhang notes that the Urban Housing Demolition and Relocation Management Regulation "has a focus on the advancement of urban development, and as such it does not make the fair process for takings a priority. On the contrary, it has a bias against owners of households." (p. 360.)

Curbs Over Uyghurs' Rights
While underscoring shortcomings in cultural heritage preservation and continuing problems with property seizure and resettlement in China, the Kashgar demolition project also draws attention to broader problems in China's policies in ethnic minority areas and in the XUAR in particular. Although the XUAR is an officially designated ethnic minority autonomous region with legally stipulated guarantees for "ethnic minorities’ right to administer their internal affairs" (Preamble, Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law) and measures to protect ethnic minority culture and cultural heritage, the Kashgar project highlights the failure of the government to protect such rights in practice. (For specific Chinese legal provisions on ethnic minorities that focus on cultural heritage protection, see, e.g., article 38 of the Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law and article 25 of Provisions on Implementing the Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law.) The project, noted by a source in the New York Times article to have "unusually strong backing high in the government," accompanies longstanding policies of control over the Uyghur population, including harsh security measures and steps to dilute ethnic identity and promote assimilation, as noted in the Congressional-Executive Commission on China 2008 Annual Report and recent CECC analyses (1, 2, 3). The level of repression in the region undermines residents' ability to protect their rights, even as more space for challenging government abuses has opened up in China.

Additional Resources

* For more information on responses within China to the project, see a survey posted on the Bulletin Board Service (BBS) of the Uyghur-language Web site Xabnam.com (also available in Latin script on the Uyghur American Association Web site's discussion forum). See also a discussion on the BBS of the Uyghur-language Web site Diyarim.
* For more information on China's framework for historic preservation and an examination of preservation projects in Beijing, see Daniel B. Abramson, "The Aesthetics of City-scale Preservation Policy in Beijing," Planning Perspectives, Vol. 22, No. 2 (April 2007): 129-166 and Daniel B. Abramson, "Beijing's Preservation Policy and the Fate of the Siheyuan," Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review, Vol. 13, No. 1 (Fall 2001): 7-22.
* For more information on property rights, see the CECC Virtual Academy page on Property Rights Resources.
* For more information on China's legal framework for ethnic minority rights, see the "Special Focus" section within the CECC 2005 Annual Report and Section II--Ethnic Minority Rights in the CECC 2007 and 2008 Annual Reports.
* For information on conditions in the XUAR, see Section IV--Xinjiang, in the CECC 2008 Annual Report.

End of the Silk Road for historic trading hub of Kashgar


End of the Silk Road for historic trading hub of Kashgar
Demolition workers in Kashgar

(Jane Macartney)

Bulldozers are already knocking down centuries-old homes in Kashgar
Image :1 of 3
Jane Macartney in Kashgar

Today is the last day for residents of one of the last surviving ancient cities in China to claim a bonus for agreeing to move out to make way for the wrecking ball.

After the offer expires, the only inducement may be force.

Bulldozers are already crashing through the packed-mud walls of centuries-old homes. Yellow-helmeted workers toss bricks into wheelbarrows as they clear the rubble.

The demolition of swaths of the Old Town of Kashgar is being carried out in the name of modernisation and safety. The famed trading hub on the Silk Road, on which caravans carrying silk and jade from China crossed with merchants from Central Asia bringing furs and spices, will effectively disappear.


Walls throughout the town are stencilled with signs exhorting residents to support the makeover to prevent the damage wrought by last year’s massive earthquake in southwestern Sichuan province that killed 90,000 people.

Many residents of the old quarter, members of the Muslim Uighur minority, are unconvinced.

One old man, his beard white, taps a mud-and-straw wall. “These houses have withstood earthquakes for 2,000 years. They have wood inside to absorb the shock.” He gestures to a renovated building next door. “People are supposed to use these hard bricks. But look at the cement. There are gaps and it’s poor quality. Maybe this would fall more quickly.”

City authorities have decided that most of these one and two-storey buildings must be razed. A small area visited by tourists seeking a flavour of Kashgar’s rich history will be preserved. Uighur residents, already distrustful of a Government that many regard as an occupation force, even doubt that.

An elderly businessman, who refused to be identified for fear of retribution, said: “They don’t tell us anything. We don’t understand why they do this. Anyway, I don’t believe anything they say.” He is too frightened even to say who “they” are. He uses two letters, “GV ". He means the Government.

Residents of the old city are reluctant to talk. Their fear is palpable. One gestures down the street. “The police are here. We must be careful.” In a house destined to disappear, a young girl slams the door into her rose-filled courtyard on visitors who ask about her home.

The Government plans to spend $440 million (£270 million) to move 65,000 Uighur households – about 220,000 people – into modern housing. The aim is safer housing but other factors are at work.

With a huge government stimulus package to boost the economy, authorities now have the money to tear down a warren of narrow alleys in which they fear Muslim Uighurs could foment separatist unrest. Days before last year’s Olympics two Uighurs rammed a lorry into a group of young police officers on a morning jog and then leapt out and attacked them with knives, killing 17. This month officials said that they had wrapped up seven terrorist cells in Kashgar.

Non-governmental organisations are anxious that yet another remnant of China’s rapidly disappearing past is to vanish. The Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Centre has issued an appeal to save the Old Town, saying that the threat to Kashgar is more serious even than that to the Chinese capital’s old alleyways or to Lhasa.

It said: “Primarily due to its relatively distant location, information… is very hard to come by, hence so little monitoring and criticism on the poor preservation work of the local government.”

Wu Dianting, a Beijing professor of regional planning who has studied the city, says that such large-scale raw-earth towns are now rare anywhere in the world. He describes them as well adapted for the desert region, being warm in winter and cool in summer. He has asked city authorities to reconsider. “Demolition would be a terrible pity.”

Families are less concerned about their cultural heritage than about having a roof over their heads, and one under which they have sheltered for generations.

Those who can afford to strengthen their existing homes and add a second storey may stay. The elderly businessman said: “Most people don’t agree. But they are poor. They have to move.”

The extent of resistance is reflected in the forest of banners and wall slogans exhorting support for the improvements. One offered a bonus of 200 yuan (£20) a square metre for those who left by June 6; those staying until June 18 will be eligible for only 100 yuan. After that they will get nothing.

Not all are opposed. One elderly Muslim merchant in an embroidered skullcap chatted between stalls selling grilled mutton kebabs as flat bread baked in earthen ovens and artisans beat copper pots. He said: “The new houses are much cleaner. They have a bathroom and a kitchen. It’s good to have proper sanitation.”

He will still come down to the Old Town to gossip with friends around the main Id Kah Mosque. His son shrugs about the prospect of life in a block of flats. “What can you do? What can you do? We have no choice.”

* Have your say

This would be a terrible mistake. I have been in Kaskgar twice over the last eight years and have seen things changing. The old town is one of the main tourist attractions in Kashgar and I think quite unique in the world. I am really shocked reading this piece of news.

Ann, Nanjing, China

A substantial part of China's GDP rests on construction (having knocked something down first). That has helped to boost the economy to 7% growth this year (World Bank forecast). It's ruthless growth. Someone has to pay. Out of the ashes, the phoenix flies? Not one entirely to my liking

ed, london,

Developing countries are not museums for other peoples satisfaction. The residents will get new properties and sanitaion - would you like to live in a mud brick home?

Dan Lee , Melbourne , Australia

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Xinjiang's free radical: a Uyghur's sacrifice

Rebiya Kadeer, the 62-year-old leader-in-exile of China's Uyghur muslim minority, faced a few supporters and friendly journalists on the stairs of a federal courthouse in Washington DC last November. The Circuit Court had just ruled that 17 Uyghur muslims would remain in American military detention at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, despite a district court ruling six weeks earlier that had found they were not terrorists.

"They are innocent men," she said. "When you compare them with terrorists, it's very unfair. That's why I think America will let them stay [in the country]."

Kadeer, who is about five feet tall and favours girlish salt and pepper pigtails crowned with a traditional kufi-like hat, had good reason to have faith in her adopted homeland. In 2005, after she had spent six years in a Chinese prison, the US State Department and John Kamm, a former head of the American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong, negotiated her release. The US government-funded National Endowment for Democracy provides a US$249,000 annual grant to her Uyghur American Association (UAA).

From a cramped, bland office space a couple of blocks from the White House - the firm next door speculates on multifamily real estate - she struggles to uphold the rights of more than 10 million Uyghurs, who inhabit China's far western Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, an area they prefer to call East Turkistan.

The US State Department has recently decried Beijing's policy towards the Uyghurs and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton reiterated that judgment during her first visit to China, in February. Nonetheless, the US has not pressed the issue, preferring not to antagonise Beijing.

When Kadeer talks about human rights abuses in Xinjiang, her voice rises.

"I was treated as an enemy of the state because I asked the Chinese government, `Why won't you allow the Uyghur people and the Chinese people to live in peace and harmony? And why don't you respect the Uyghur people's rights to their education and culture.' But the government doesn't want to hear that."
Kadeer's struggle has been at times lonely and difficult. There are about 1,000 Uyghurs in America but the post September 11 phobia about Muslims has not helped their cause.

"Tibetans are treated well in the west because they are Buddhist and considered peaceful," says Alim Seytoff, who runs UAA sister organisation Uyghur Human Rights Project. "The Tibetans are victims and we are victims, too."
In a year of milestones in the mainland - the 20th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown, 10 years since repression of the Falun Gong began and the 50th anniversary of the Dalai Lama's exile - few people are aware that it is 60 years since the Communist Party annexed Xinjiang.

Like that of many of the peoples of Central Asia, the Uyghur experience has been shaped by war and conquest. The two brief periods in the 20th century when they weren't under the thumb of the Russians or the Han Chinese - the first East Turkistan Republic lasted nine months in 1933 and the second lasted for five years, between 1944 and 1949 - loom large in the Uyghur consciousness.

In August 1949, after the Communists had all but defeated Chiang Kai-shek's Kuomintang, Mao Zedong planned to meet with seven leaders of the Second East Turkistan Republic and negotiate their role within the country. The plane carrying the seven Uyghurs crashed, an event that wasn't reported until four months later.

"There were rumours about a plot from Beijing; a plot from Moscow," says Gardner Bovingdon, an Indiana University professor and Xinjiang expert. "There is a popular Uyghur notion that the Uyghur were going to negotiate [a self-determining role in China]," Bovingdon continues. "The bodies were never found, the plane itself was never found and there remains a controversy."

"The Soviets and the Chinese [used the plane crash] basically to deceive the Uyghur people," claims Kadeer. "And then they selected a puppet to represent us - that's how we became part of China. They had the Bingtuan, [also known as] the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps, strategically located near Uyghur communities to monitor them and suppress them if necessary. We're not able to get out and get our message out."

According to the Han narrative, Xinjiang is traditionally part of China and the meeting was just a formality. The Bingtuan, an economic, semi-military organisation that has built roads and infrastructure, has brought opportunity and desperately needed development to an area that in 1955, like its neighbour Tibet, became an autonomous region.

Common to people who consider themselves stateless, the struggle for self-determination is all-consuming. "We have so many heroes who rose up against Chinese rule," says Kadeer, who was two years old when the plane crashed. "All of them were imprisoned or executed."

Kadeer's father, a respected community leader, battled the Nationalists and her grandfather helped burn down a Manchu dynasty palace.

In her 2007 German-language autobiography, Dragon Fighter, which has recently been translated into English, Kadeer describes a childhood marked by profound fear and dislocation. She was born in Altai prefecture, in the far north of Xinjiang; the borders of Russia, Kazakhstan and Mongolia form an X across the Altai mountain range. In the village where she was raised, Uyghurs lived in the centre and ethnic Kazakhs in the surrounding mountains.

Han Chinese were an abstraction until she was 13, when the Bingtuan entered her village. They ordered her family to leave, destroyed their house and confiscated her dogs. Her father remained in Altai. Her mother, Kadeer and four siblings drove for weeks to Aksu, near the Kyrgyzstan border.

Two years later, she married Abdirim, a Uyghur 13 years her senior. He was an abusive husband and theirs was a loveless marriage. At 15, she became a mother and she went on to have five more with Abdirim, who was a manager in a state bank.

The hardship of her early years contrasts with Kadeer's later success. As the Asian Wall Street Journal noted in a 1994 profile, it was literally "a rags to riches story". After leaving Abdirim, she used the money she made as a washerwoman to trade in commodities. She eventually made enough to open a shopping mall in downtown Urumqi, Xinjiang's capital. By the early 1990s, Kadeer ran an import-export empire that bridged China and Central Asia.

She had remarried, her second husband being a Uyghur professor and government critic named Sidik Rouzi. During the Cultural Revolution, Rouzi served a decade in prison for counter-revolutionary activities. The marriage set up a complicated balancing act for Kadeer; her business success was held up as an example of Uyghur progress in Chinese society but it also afforded her a platform for advocacy.
As a member of the Chinese People's Political Consultive Conference (CPPCC), she travelled to Beijing, where she protested against the mass migration into Xinjiang of Han, sent to fill energy and agriculture jobs. In 1996, the still-outspoken Rouzi fled to Washington. And on February 5, 1997, demonstrations in the city of Gulja (also known as Yining) turned brutal. An Amnesty International report on the incident concluded that "hundreds, possibly thousands, lost their lives or were seriously injured". An estimated 50 Uyghurs, detained in bitterly cold cells, suffered frostbite.

After the Gulja incident, Kadeer publicised the testimony of witnesses of the repression.
"My situation became extremely bad," Kadeer recalls. "Basically, the Chinese authorities severely disrupted my import-export business. My passport and my colleagues' passports were confiscated." She'd also angered the most powerful man in the region, Xinjiang party secretary Wang Lequan.
By 1998, the government had stripped her of her position in the CPPCC and Wang had began publicly denigrating her.

"Her commercial activities have been very poor over the last few years," Wang told reporters at a Beijing press conference that year. "Her reputation in business circles isn't very good either ... Moreover, her husband, Sidik, has engaged in activities to split the state from outside our borders."

Things soon grew worse. On August 11, 1999, en route to meet a US congressional delegation investigating human rights abuses, Kadeer was arrested. She was convicted of revealing state secrets: mailing widely-available newspaper clippings to Rouzi.

During her six years in prison, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the US State Department made pleas for her release. She was treated better than the other prisoners, she says.
"When I describe the treatment of the Uyghur prisoners, it sounds like an outrageous claim," she says. "I have witnessed the kind of torture you would see during the second world war."

In prison, she writes in Dragon Fighter, her jailers encouraged her Han cellmate, a convicted killer, to drive her crazy.

Kadeer's situation improved when Kamm intervened. The American stepped down as president of AmCham in 1990 and now runs San Francisco-based NGO Dui Hua, which has been instrumental in winning the release or improving the treatment of more than 250 political prisoners in the mainland. Kamm negotiated a sentence reduction for Kadeer. He then secured an early release by convincing the US to drop a United Nations resolution critical of mainland human rights abuses.

"It was more difficult than most transactions I've been involved with," Kamm recalls. "There were several high-ranking Chinese officials who opposed releasing Rebiya Kadeer, including the party secretary in Xinjiang, Wang Lequan."

Kadeer landed at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport on March 17, 2005. She was greeted by five of her children and Rouzi, who was waving both the US and the East Turkistan flags. Her children had grown up and Rouzi's thick black hair and eyebrows had turned white. For her part, she'd gained international renown - garnering the attention of Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch and earning Norway's Thorolf Rafto Memorial Prize for Human Rights.

The political landscape had changed, too. In the uncertainty following September 11, Beijing conflated all Uyghur independence groups with the East Turkistan Islamic Movement (ETIM), which has been inconclusively linked to terrorist group al-Qaeda. Chinese agents were even allowed into Guantanamo to interrogate the Uyghur detainees, who had been captured in Afghanistan and Pakistan's tribal areas.

What is not often mentioned in the media is that for Uyghurs fleeing Xinjiang, the Afghanistan and Pakistan borders are the safest places to exit because their ethnic cousins in the other border states - Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan - are dependent on China's voracious energy consumption and have signed up to Beijing's "war on Uyghur terror" through the Shanghai Co-operation Organisation.

China's soft power extends even further into the region. Beijing is building a pipeline through Xinjiang to the oil and gas fields of Central Asia and connecting it to the mainland-funded Arabian Sea port in Gwadar, Pakistan.

Observers such as pro-democracy NGO Freedom House believe that nine Uyghur "terrorists" recently captured in Pakistan's tribal areas were extradited to the mainland on April 27 to appease Beijing.
Few countries want to risk arousing the wrath of China. Since the 2006 release of six Uyghur prisoners from Guantanamo Bay to Albania, the US has reportedly approached many countries to find sanctuary for the remaining 17. None has dared take them in - not even Albania - although Australia is now considering a request to accept 10, having denied two previous requests.

"My hope is that these Uyghurs - if not all of them, some of them - can be released into the US and the others can be released into European democracies," says Kadeer. "Of course, the ideal situation is for all the Uyghurs to come [to the US]. It would be good for us to assist them." And there is a secondary reason.

"[It] would make illegitimate the Chinese government's use of the terrorist label," she says.

But the mere suggestion of Islamic terror is enough to make even the most sympathetic politician think twice. When reports surfaced early last month that six of the Guantanamo Uyghurs might be released in the US, Frank Wolf, a Republican congressman representing Virginia who Kadeer had counted as an ally a few months earlier and who has supported pro-Uyghur resolutions, grew nervous. Wolf sent Attorney-General Eric Holder a letter protesting any plan to release them in the US. Since most of the Uyghurs in the greater Washington area live in his district, the detainees would probably have ended up on Wolf's doorstep.

"We're feeling betrayed by Congressman Frank Wolf," says Nury Turkel, the Washington-based aviation lawyer who founded UAA. "It's unclear why he is turning his back on us now. Congressman Wolf should know that these men are victims of communism and prisoners of politics. They harbour no ill-intent or hostility towards America."

In large Xinjiang cities, such as Kashgar and Urumqi, people have learned to be cautious.

"If you are a Uyghur there are rules about congregating," says Nick Zaller, an American epidemiologist who worked on Xinjiang's HIV problem in an Urumqi clinic between 2002 and 2004. "No more than three people can congregate.

"I never directly had any conversations about [Kadeer]," he says. "People are careful about what they say. A lot of times they will [only] talk in general. In my experience, a lot of people are not talking overtly about this."

Seytoff - a former divorce lawyer who came to America as a student in 1996, became politically active in Uyghur causes and can't return to his homeland - is less delicate when describing the situation in Xinjiang. "You can imagine the Jews in Germany before the second world war, how terrified they were," he says. "The only difference is the Chinese government has not required Uyghurs to wear a Star of David because Uyghurs don't look like Han Chinese."

In the run up to the Beijing Olympics, tensions in Xinjiang again boiled over. As many as 33 people are believed to have been killed in uprisings and attacks, which Beijing blamed on the ETIM. (With the mainland's media restrictions, accurate numbers and reports are hard to obtain.) Once the attention died down, Beijing launched a vicious crackdown during the religious month of Ramadan that banned fasting, beards and veils, according to the US State Department.

She may have escaped to America but the long arm of the Chinese state still reaches Kadeer. Despite a US House of Representatives non-binding resolution passed last September urging their release, two of her sons are in mainland prisons: Ablikim Abdiriyim is serving a nine-year sentence for secessionism; Alim Abdiriyim a seven-year sentence for tax evasion. Two daughters are trapped under virtual house arrest in Xinjiang.

Amnesty International believes the mainland government is harassing and jailing her family to silence her. Kadeer says even her grandchildren have been targeted and forced out of school. She says a working group has been created to dismantle the business empire she built and allegations of tax evasion and financial irregularities have been made. Little is left. But Kadeer has no plans to hold her tongue.

"I believe I should continue what I'm doing because the world should know our situation," she says.

"Somebody has to speak up on behalf of the Uyghur people.

"[The Han Chinese in Xinjiang] enjoy a great life; we enjoy hell," she says, showing a rare flash of anger.

Down the hall from the conference room where she receives guests, inside her small office, there is a decade-old picture of Kadeer. She wears a flowing, lacy white dress. A white headscarf covers half her head. She is perfectly made up, has smooth skin and immaculate jet-black hair that is swept up into a peak. Her dark eyes burn with intensity.

Rebiya Kadeer looks very different today. Her hair is flecked with strands of grey; her face seems permanently creased with worry. When asked whether she regrets trading luxury for struggle, she doesn't hesitate.

"Not very much. I am doing what I want to do so I consider that big wealth. For me, freedom is a very important thing. I don't want to compare my life then with my life now."

On the wall beside her, the goal and the cost are on view. There is a bright blue East Turkistan flag on one side of the room while the other side features pictures of two handsome Uyghur men: her imprisoned sons.